Photo:Phil McCarten/Invision for the Television Academy/AP Images

Creative Emmy winners

Phil McCarten/Invision for the Television Academy/AP Images

Nick Offermantook home his first Emmy at the 75th annual Creative ArtsEmmy Awardson Saturday, winning Outstanding Guest Actor in a Drama Series for his performance inThe Last of Us.

“Fortune presents gifts not according to the book," he said in his acceptance speech.

Offerman also saluted Cromwell and thanked his “magnificent” partnerMegan Mullally, who had previously encouraged him to take on the role of Bill, a paranoid survivalist, who unexpectedly falls in love with unexpected trespasser Frank (Bartlett).

While answering questions from the press afterward, Offerman suggested there could be a whole miniseries that revolved around Bill and Frank’s decades-long relationship, quipping, “It could be a musical.”

Here is a look at the six nominees.

Liane Hentscher/HBO

Nick Offerman HBO The Last of Us Season 1 - Episode 3

Offerman and Bartlett broke hearts in episode 3, “Long, Long Time,” playing two men who fell into each other’s orbits and hearts in the wake of a global apocalypse. From reluctant friends to decades-long lovers, skittish survivalist Bill (Offerman) and extroverted nomad Frank (Bartlett) saved each other before choosing not to live without each other. They found life’s only remaining purpose in each other, bringing viewers to tears to the tune of the 1970Linda Ronstadtsong that gave the episode its name.

Murray Bartlett - The Last of Us Season 1 - Episode 3

Bartlett is not only a double nominee this year — he also earned a 2023 outstanding supporting actor nomination for playing real-life choreographerNick De Noiain Hulu’s limited seriesWelcome to Chippendales— he’s also a returning Emmy winner aftertaking home a 2022 supporting actor statuettefor his breakout turn in season 1 ofThe White Lotus.

This year was Offerman’s fourth Emmy nomination after three shared nods withMaking Itco-hostAmy Poehler. (His and Bartlett’s costarAnna Torvalso scored a guest actress nod for her three-episode arc, which included “Long, Long Time.")

Lamar Johnson - The Last of Us Season 1 - Episode 5

Johnson and Woodard played brave but doomed brothers in episodes 4 and 5 ofThe Last of Us. Johnson’s Henry, a.k.a. “The Most Wanted Man in Kansas,” would do anything to protect his Deaf younger brother Sam — even if it meant taking on the risky mission of helpingPedro PascalandBella Ramsey’s travelers Joel and Ellie as they eluded pursuit of a relentless local power player Kathleen (Melanie Lynskey, who is also in the outstanding guest actress race).

Keivonn Woodard - The Last of Us Season 1 - Episode 5

Johnson and Woodard’s nominations were their first, with 10-year-old Woodard making history as both the youngest actor to ever to be nominated in this category as well as the first ever Black Deaf actor to receive an Emmy nod.

Macall Polay/HBO

Emmy Awards Guest Actor/Actress James Cromwell

Cromwell rounded out his four-season run on the darkly hilarious family drama with a third nomination for portraying Logan Roy’s (Brian Cox) crusty, liberal brother Ewan. Perhaps earning Cromwell this year’s nod was his stirring, scathing delivery of an impromptu eulogy for Logan: “I loved him, I suppose, and I suppose some of you did too…. Now and then darkened the skies a little. Closed men’s hearts. Fed that dark flame in men, the hard mean hard-relenting flame that keeps their heart warm while another grows cold.”

Moayed, anotherSuccessionOG, was also a 2022 nomination in this category for playing agnostic venture capitalist Stewy Hosseini, whose billions continued to flow even as — and probably because — his allegiance to Kendall Roy (Jeremy Strong) shifted and whipped as quickly as the winds of Wall Street.

Peter Kramer/HBO

Succession Emmy Awards Guest Actor/Actress Arian Moayed

Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free daily newsletterto stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

SeePEOPLE’s full coverageof the 75th annual Primetime Emmy Awards, which are airing live from the Peacock Theater in Los Angeles Monday at 8 p.m. ET on Fox.

source: people.com