When you purchase through liaison on our land site , we may earn an affiliate charge . Here ’s how it work .
When the newly split up motivational speaker Gerald Rogers engage to Facebook , posting a list of bits of man and wife advice he said he like he had known , his heartfelt advice was hear , liked and shared by thou of people .
While Rogers ' inclination has certainly assume a chord , experts on marriage and relationships say they have a range of reaction to the advice . While some of the tips on the lean are great , they say , others may not curb up very well for some citizenry . What ’s more , crucial pieces of the teaser are abstracted from the list , they say . [ 6 Scientific Tips for a Successful matrimony ]
Can the keys to a happy relationship be found in one man’s list of tips?
LiveScience ask experts to count in on Rogers ' advice , and to choose which top from the list they feel is most significant . Here ’s what they said :
A beautiful firearm of verse
Dr. Mark Banschick , a head-shrinker in Katonah , N.Y. , and author of " The Intelligent Divorce " ( Intelligent Book Press , 2010 ) , said what struck him the most was the poetic beauty of Rogers ' realization .
" It ’s a beautiful statement of how a piece can make a woman finger especial , andlive life in a full way , " Banschick said . " We need people like this to enliven us . "
Beyond the poetical inhalation , an of import part of the advice is Rogers ' point in time about not endeavor to vary your partner , Banschick read .
" It ’s not your business to switch or fix her , " Rogers write . " Your caper is to love her as she is , with no expectation of her ever exchange . And if she changes , love what she becomes , whether it ’s what you need or not . "
" That ’s very hard-nosed and solid advice for everybody , " Banschick say . " Make certain you find oneself the right mortal — you ca n’t switch a person . Marry the right person . "
Forgiveness is slick
Jane Greer , a marriage and family therapist and author of " What About Me ? cease Selfishness from Ruining Your human relationship " ( Sourcebooks Casablanca , 2010 ) , say she ascertain the absolute majority of Rogers ' points terrific .
" He talks about focusing on the positive things , stay on in the second , working on the marriage , being aware that you have to keep the love alive and you ca n’t just take it for give , " Greer said .
But some of the advice , Greer say , necessitate more limpidity ; otherwise , it could forbid some couples from really solve their trouble . [ I Do n’t : 5 Myths About Marriage ]
For example , Rogers wrote , " Forgive straight off , and focus on the future rather than carry system of weights from the past . Do n’t lease your account hold you hostage . "
But Greer enunciate , " Just saying ' forgive ' is unreasonable , unrealistic and would perpetuate citizenry ’s struggling . "
For example , in a marriage in which there ’s been infidelity , prevarication or hurtful behavior , pardon is n’t simple , she said . " The expectation that you ’re just going to forgive somebody and get over it is not only unrealistic , but it can really take the mortal who ’s been wounded by the hurtful conduct to a vulnerable space , and a place that it might chance again . "
So , what can people do if they ca n’t find it in themselves to forgive immediately , as Rogers order ? " Forgiveness is the first footprint , " Greer say . " Your partner has to apologize to you , and then you want to be able to say , ' I forgive you , but how are things go to be unlike ? ' “ Greer said . The partner who committed the adultery or discover the trust postulate to be unforced to vary , rebuild the trust and make certain it does n’t happen again .
Greer ’s preferred crest among Rogers ' advice is the invitation to " settle in love over and over and over , " she said .
" That heedfulness of fall in sexual love again and again , continue to arise with your partner and fall in love with who they ’ve become . That ’s what stay fresh the relationship moral force , " Greer added .
However , not all change is good , or should be stand .
" There are thing that are simply your bottom personal line of credit — you ca n’t accept and you ca n’t live with them , and they need to be compromise around , " she said .
Learning human relationship attainment
Denver psychologist Susan Heitler , writer of The Power of Two Workbook : Communication Skills for a Strong & Loving Marriage ( New Harbinger Publications , 2003 ) also state Rogers ' point about not trying to change your partner was her preferred hint .
However , the point itself is not enough , Heitler said . Most citizenry involve to focus in , looking at what they can do otherwise in reception to problems , and learn the skills for discussing difficulty .
" If both people in a relationship check skills for lecture through conflict in a cooperative and fat way of life , both maturate and change for the better throughout their years together , " Heitler say . " Without the attainment , relationships are at risk for a long , gradual , or short and extortionate , downhill slide . "
Heitler also enunciate there ’s one important bit of advice missing : to centre ongood mind .
" The biggest error most men make is deficient listening , " she said . " They ignore , they do n’t take seriously their wife ’s care , or they debate what she say , responding to what they see as improper and missing the tip of what she is trying to communicate . "
Some world seem to be more interested in being correct , or making a better point , than in respond in a helpful way , Heitler said . Research has testify that such human being are more likely to get disunite , while a goodpredictor of a successful marriageis men ’s " responsivity " — that is , taking the married woman ’s concern seriously and responding with helpful action , she said .
